Suggestions for 3D Solid Modeling of Tube Structures
This document is to assist designers in preparing information suitable for our tube profiling process.
These methods and suggestions should be compatible with most 3D solid modeling packages.
Our tube fabrication team is most familiar with ‘Solidworks’ software and produces tube structure as a
‘weldment’ part file. Some advantages are:
one file contains the complete parametric information and therefore can be sent without
related attachment files or libraries
trim and extend features are quick and easy
profile library of tube sizes is convenient
one file to update with any changes to tube sizes or geometry
A disadvantage is that the file size becomes large especially when the drawing files are created.
Each structure starts by establishing an initial reference plane. This plane is usually through the
centerline of the structure. This establishes the profile of the structure.
Create a 3D wire frame representing the tube centerlines of the major structural tubes ensuring
the parametric features are fully defined as the structure grows
Build the tube structure on the solid model generally in the same order as one would build the
structure on the shop floor
Add the tubes with the correct od and wall thickness and extrude along the lines and curves. Do
not combine lines and paths into one solid body until the structure is complete. The trimming
features are generally more reliable this way.
Trim/extend or cut/extrude each tube as it is added to the existing tubes in the structure. This is
less confusing than determining the trim sequence with all tubes in the structure.
Ensure the parametric design features and geometry are fully defined as you proceed.
Avoid ‘mirroring’ tubes. Mirrored tubes generally have unique profile paths and require separate
profile programs to produce. Trim features are more robust. Changes are easier to apply
downstream.
Once all the tubes in the solid model are added and trimmed, combine the tube segments as
required to produce single tube components. This applies mostly to curved, formed or bent tubes.
Assign each tube in the solid model a unique part number. Using ‘solidworks’, this is done in the
cutlist.
At this point, the 3D model is just a ‘cartoon’. The required information to produce this structure
is not readily accessible or organized and the dimensional design cannot be checked easily.
An assembly drawing with material list must be created to itemize the number of pieces. Create a
drawing with an isometric view, bill of material and add balloons for each tube component.
Create a drawing with the 3 main views (side, front, top) plus any important section views. Add
overall dimensions, station dimensions and layout dimensions to verify the design configuration.
These dimensions will also be required to assemble and build the tube structure on the shop
floor.
Review and check the design:
confirm the design dimensions
confirm tube sizes
confirm all tubes are shown
review all trims at tube clusters
Confirm that bend radii and tube sizes are compatible with available bending dies and
manufacturing procedures.
Produce a part file for each tube in the weldment maintaining the parametric link to the solid
model weldment.
Open each part file for the round straight tubes. Visually check the end trims to confirm complete
end trims. Then, insert a new or temporary coordinate system such that the ‘z’ axis is aligned
with the primary axis of the tube. Locate the coordinate vertex anywhere between the 2 ends.
Point the positive ‘z’ direction toward the tube end with the ‘most complex’ profile. Save this file
in ‘iges’ format which will no longer have a parametric link to previous files. This file must
represent a single solid body.
Square tubes require an additional step to round tubes. Also align the ‘x’ and ‘y’ axis
perpendicular to the faces of the square tube profile.
Tubes with Bends:
Send the formed tubes as an iges file without adding a new coordinate system and accompany
this with a drawing file.
VR3 will import this into solidworks, ‘straighten’ the tube while maintaining the profile
orientations, adjust the length to suit bend allowances, profile the tube and then bend the tube into the
final shape.
Please review bend features with us prior to approving the final design to ensure compatability
with bend dies and manufacturing procedures.
Send the iges files and material list to us for manufacturing the profiled tubes.
From this file we can extract the profile data and generate the cnc tool path for the tube profiler.
We will profile, label, package and send a set of tubes ready for weld assembly
Notes:
Feathered faces: Our tube profiling process always cuts the tube perpendicular to the tube surface. Our
programming path will eliminate the ‘feathered’ edges which result from 3d modelling. This
perpendicular cut to the surface is ideal for welding and results in a complete tube to tube contact
around the perimeter.